Arthur Buttman is the younger of the two Buttman brothers and a central figure in the life of the protagonist, Georgie. He grows up on the family farm in rural Australia during the late 19th century, fully aware that Georgie is not his biological sister but an adopted child brought home by his father. Despite this knowledge, he treats her with unwavering kindness and devotion from childhood through adulthood.

In terms of personality, Arthur is characterized by his gentle, selfless, and empathetic nature. He is often presented as a foil to his older brother, Abel, who is more passionate, impulsive, and brooding. Where Abel’s love for Georgie can be possessive and driven by his own desires, Arthur’s affection is defined by a quiet and enduring commitment to Georgie’s happiness. He consistently prioritizes her feelings and well-being above his own, even when it causes him personal pain. This self-sacrificing trait is a defining aspect of his character, as he is willing to step aside or endure hardship if it means Georgie will be safe and content.

Arthur’s primary motivation throughout the story is his deep, unrequited love for Georgie. However, unlike his brother, he does not aggressively pursue her or allow his feelings to create conflict for her. Instead, his actions are driven by a desire to protect her and see her smile. This motivation leads him to follow Georgie when she travels to England, both to watch over her and to remain close to her. His role in the narrative is that of the steadfast, supportive figure. While Georgie falls in love with the nobleman Lowell J. Gray, and Abel struggles with his own turbulent emotions, Arthur provides a stable and comforting presence. He is often the mediator in family conflicts, such as when he tries to soften the harsh words of his mother, Mary, toward Georgie.

Arthur shares his most significant relationship with Georgie, built on a lifetime of sibling intimacy and his hidden romantic feelings. His dynamic with his brother, Abel, is also crucial; they are rivals in love, yet Arthur rarely engages in direct conflict with Abel, preferring to let Georgie make her own choices. His relationship with his mother is complex, as he often finds himself defending Georgie from Mary’s resentment while still trying to remain a loyal son. Arthur also forms connections in England, where he becomes an object of affection for Maria, the daughter of the villainous Duke Dangering, though he does not reciprocate her feelings as he is devoted to Georgie.

Throughout the series, Arthur undergoes subtle but significant development. Initially a kind but passive young man, his experiences in England force him to mature considerably. He faces grave danger, including being imprisoned and tortured by the sadistic Irwin Dangering after discovering a conspiracy against the Queen. This ordeal showcases his inner strength and courage, revealing that his gentleness is not born of weakness. He endures this suffering without betraying his principles, and his rescue becomes a major objective for Georgie and Abel. By the end of the story, Arthur has proven himself to be not only a loving and selfless figure but also a resilient and brave individual.

Regarding notable abilities, Arthur does not possess any extraordinary skills or powers. His strengths lie in his emotional fortitude, his capacity for empathy, and his unwavering loyalty. He is a capable farmer and outdoorsman, having grown up working on the family ranch, and demonstrates resourcefulness and endurance during the perilous events in London. His most significant ability is his profound emotional intelligence, which allows him to understand Georgie’s feelings and act in her best interest, even when it means sacrificing his own chance at happiness.