The premise begins with a heated online argument. An author, whose Boys Love manga The Odd-Eyed Butler is finally being adapted into an anime, gets into a furious debate with a self-proclaimed Fan of the Counts Daughter. This fan aggressively criticizes the storys submissive butler character known as the uke and insists on shipping the dominant viscount, or seme, with the villainess counts daughter instead. In the middle of this online fight, the authors computer short-circuits, killing them instantly via electric shock.

The author wakes up to discover they have been reincarnated into the world of their own creation, but not as a powerful figure. They now inhabit the body of the very uke butler character they were defending. The situation quickly escalates when they realize their online rival has also been reincarnated, taking on the role of the count's daughter, the villainess of the story. This rival immediately begins making romantic advances on the viscount, effectively trying to rewrite the narrative and ship a heterosexual couple the author never intended.

The central conflict revolves around the author, now trapped as the submissive butler, fighting to protect their original story and characters. They must fend off the villainesss schemes to hijack the plot and ensure the integrity of their Boys Love narrative survives this unwanted interference. The setting is the fictional world of The Odd-Eyed Butler, a fantasy environment where the author must navigate their new role while battling a rival who has full knowledge of the original plot.

Notable narrative arcs include the initial online argument and sudden death, the shock of reincarnation as the uke butler, the confrontation with the rival reincarnated as the count's daughter, and the ongoing struggle to thwart the villainesss advances on the viscount to preserve the original BL storyline. The series is a fantasy isekai manga created by artist Kiiran and writer MJiffy, published by Kadokawa.