"Baby Dare yori Kimi ga Suki" centers on the romantic and comedic dynamics between its main characters, exploring themes of love, misunderstandings, and personal growth. The protagonist, a high school student named Aoi, finds herself entangled in a complicated relationship with her childhood friend, Haruto. Aoi has harbored feelings for Haruto for years, but her attempts to confess are repeatedly thwarted by her own insecurities and Haruto's obliviousness. The narrative delves into their evolving relationship as they navigate the challenges of adolescence, including school life, friendships, and rivalries.

Haruto, while kind-hearted, is often portrayed as clueless about Aoi's feelings, leading to numerous comedic and heartfelt moments. Aoi's determination to express her love is contrasted with her fear of rejection, creating a tension that drives much of the story. Supporting characters, such as Aoi's best friend and Haruto's classmates, add depth to the narrative by introducing subplots and additional perspectives on the central romance. These characters often serve as catalysts for key developments, pushing Aoi and Haruto to confront their emotions and misunderstandings.

The manga balances lighthearted humor with moments of emotional vulnerability, capturing the awkwardness and sincerity of young love. Miscommunications and humorous situations frequently arise, but the story also addresses deeper themes, such as self-acceptance and the courage to pursue one's desires. As the plot progresses, Aoi and Haruto's relationship undergoes significant changes, with both characters growing individually and together. The narrative concludes with a resolution that ties together the central romantic arc while leaving room for the characters' continued development.